Boileau's nontrivial surgery conjecture for nullhomotopic knots

Let YY be a closed oriented three-manifold, and let KYK\subset Y be a non-trivial nullhomotopic knot, meaning that KK is not the unknot and represents the trivial element of π1(Y)\pi_1(Y). A surgery on KK is obtained by replacing a tubular neighborhood of KK according to a non-meridional slope; it is non-trivial when the surgery slope is not the meridian.

Boileau's nontrivial surgery conjecture. A non-trivial surgery on KK never gives a manifold homeomorphic to YY in an orientation-preserving way.

This is essentially Boileau's surgery problem and is presented as a Dehn-surgery formulation related to the knot complement problem. The paper explains that the orientation-preserving condition is essential and that its results suggest the irreducibility assumption in the original problem may not be necessary; the conjecture remains open in the stated generality.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Aliakbar Daemi and Tye Lidman, “The knot complement problem for null-homotopic knots”, arXiv:2511.05472 (2025).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.