Nakamura's gauge-invariant decomposition conjecture for linear metric perturbations

Let Mϵ{{\mathscr M}}_{\epsilon} be a physical spacetime, let M{{\mathscr M}} be its background spacetime, and let habh_{ab} be a perturbative metric tensor pulled back from Mϵ{{\mathscr M}}_{\epsilon} to M{{\mathscr M}}. For gauge choices Xϵ{{\mathscr X}}_{\epsilon} and Yϵ{{\mathscr Y}}_{\epsilon}, suppose the gauge transformation is

Y ⁣habX ⁣hab=£ξ(1)gab,{}_{{{\mathscr Y}}}\!h_{ab}-{}_{{{\mathscr X}}}\!h_{ab}=\pounds_{\xi_{(1)}}g_{ab},

where gabg_{ab} is the background metric. Nakamura's gauge-invariant decomposition conjecture. There exist a tensor field Fab{{\mathscr F}}_{ab} and a vector field YaY^a such that

hab:=Fab+£Ygab,h_{ab}:={{\mathscr F}}_{ab}+\pounds_Yg_{ab},

with transformation rules

Y ⁣FabX ⁣Fab=0,Y ⁣YaX ⁣Ya=ξ(1)a.{}_{{{\mathscr Y}}}\!{{\mathscr F}}_{ab}-{}_{{{\mathscr X}}}\!{{\mathscr F}}_{ab}=0, \qquad {}_{{{\mathscr Y}}}\!Y^a-{}_{{{\mathscr X}}}\!Y^a=\xi^a_{(1)}.

This conjecture is the premise underlying Nakamura's higher-order gauge-invariant perturbation theory: Fab{{\mathscr F}}_{ab} is gauge invariant, while YaY^a carries the gauge dependence. The supplied text does not state whether the conjecture has been proved or remains open.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Kouji Nakamura, “Comparing a gauge-invariant formulation and a "conventional complete gauge-fixing approach" for l=0,1 mode perturbations on the Schwarzschild background spacetime”, arXiv:2407.21375 (2024).

Additional references

5 papers in this index state this conjecture (2021–2024). The statement above is taken from the most recent of them; the others are arXiv:2307.01587, arXiv:2110.13508, arXiv:2110.13512, arXiv:2110.13519.

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.