← All problems

Andrews–Merca averaged truncation conjecture for Jacobi's triple product

2 years old · traced to

Let m,k,R,Sm,k,R,S be positive integers with 1≤S<R/21\le S<R/2. Consider the formal power series

(−1)k−1(qS,qR−S,qR;qR)∞∑0≤n<k(−1)nq(n+12)R−nS(1−q(2n+1)S).\frac{(-1)^{k-1}}{(q^S,q^{R-S},q^{R};q^{R})_{\infty}} \sum_{0\le n<k}(-1)^nq^{\binom{n+1}{2}R-nS}(1-q^{(2n+1)S}).

Andrews–Merca's conjecture. The coefficient of qmq^m in this series is non-negative.

References

Status

Source: Nian Hong Zhou, “Positivity and tails of pentagonal number series”, arXiv:2403.06196 (2024).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open · solution reported

The conjecture was proved independently in 2015, with later combinatorial and identity-based proofs, and no unresolved challenge was found.

Andrews and Merca conjectured that the averaged truncation has nonnegative coefficients; Guo and Zeng posed the same question independently. Mao and Yee proved the conjecture independently in 2015, and subsequent work supplied further proofs.

Known results

  • Mao, 2015: algebraic proof of the conjecture.
  • Yee, 2015: independent combinatorial proof.
  • He, Ji, and Zang: later combinatorial confirmation.
  • Wang and Yee: an averaged-truncation identity whose specialization reproves the result.

2026 stronger positivity claims

A 2026 paper claims a full combinatorial proof of a stronger normalized-tail positivity statement, implying Merca’s stronger conjecture. Another 2026 paper discusses related Jacobi-theta-tail positivity. These developments report no counterexample, gap, or retraction.

Current status (as of September 2026): The exact averaged-truncation conjecture is settled by independent 2015 proofs and later confirmations; stronger related positivity claims are reported but are unverified here.

Sources

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.