The Kervaire conjecture for free products with an infinite cyclic factor
Let be a nontrivial group, set , and let \savebox{\@brx}{\m@th{\langle}}% \mathopen{\copy\@brx\kern-0.5\wd\@brx\usebox{\@brx}} w\savebox{\@brx}{\m@th{\rangle}}% \mathclose{\copy\@brx\kern-0.5\wd\@brx\usebox{\@brx}} be the normal closure of . Kervaire's conjecture. The quotient
H/\savebox{\@brx}{$\m@th{\langle}$}% \mathopen{\copy\@brx\kern-0.5\wd\@brx\usebox{\@brx}} w\savebox{\@brx}{$\m@th{\rangle}$}% \mathclose{\copy\@brx\kern-0.5\wd\@brx\usebox{\@brx}}is nontrivial for every . This is the Kervaire conjecture in the case of a free product with an infinite cyclic factor. The paper states that the conjecture remains open in general, with results for torsion-free and finite groups.
References
- Lvzhou Chen, “The Kervaire conjecture and the minimal complexity of surfaces”, arXiv:2302.09811 (2025).
Progress summary
Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.
Solutions 1
Claimed by OpenAI. Claims coefficient injectivity for unimodular one-variable equations over every group, with no torsion or cardinality hypothesis. It deduces that the free product of a nontrivial group with an infinite cyclic group cannot be normally generated by one element, for every exponent sum.See full solution
The source claims coefficient injectivity for unimodular equations over arbitrary groups and derives that a nontrivial group free-product Z cannot be normally generated by one element, including arbitrary exponent sums for that consequence.
GitHub repository: https://github.com/openai/math
- OpenAI-256-02-The-Kervaire-theorem-for-groups.pdfOpen