← All problems

C*-algebraic Schoenberg conjecture

4 years old · traced to

Let A\mathcal{A} be a C*-algebra, let d∈N∖{1}d\in\mathbb{N}\setminus\{1\}, and let

P(z)=(z−a1)(z−a2)⋯(z−ad)P(z)=(z-a_1)(z-a_2)\cdots(z-a_d)

be a polynomial over A\mathcal{A} with a1,…,ad∈Aa_1,\ldots,a_d\in\mathcal{A}. Suppose that its formal derivative has the factorization

P′(z)=d(z−b1)(z−b2)⋯(z−bd−1)P'(z)=d(z-b_1)(z-b_2)\cdots(z-b_{d-1})

on A\mathcal{A}, where b1,…,bd−1∈Ab_1,\ldots,b_{d-1}\in\mathcal{A}. C-algebraic Schoenberg conjecture.* The inequalities

∑k=1d−1bkbk∗≤1d2(∑j=1daj)(∑j=1daj)∗+d−2d∑j=1dajaj∗\sum_{k=1}^{d-1}b_kb_k^*\leq \frac{1}{d^2}\left(\sum_{j=1}^{d}a_j\right)\left(\sum_{j=1}^{d}a_j\right)^*+\frac{d-2}{d}\sum_{j=1}^{d}a_ja_j^*

and

∑k=1d−1bk∗bk≤1d2(∑j=1daj)∗(∑j=1daj)+d−2d∑j=1daj∗aj\sum_{k=1}^{d-1}b_k^*b_k\leq \frac{1}{d^2}\left(\sum_{j=1}^{d}a_j\right)^*\left(\sum_{j=1}^{d}a_j\right)+\frac{d-2}{d}\sum_{j=1}^{d}a_j^*a_j

should hold. This extends the classical Schoenberg inequality from complex polynomials to C*-algebraic polynomials. The paper proves the conjecture for degree 22; its general validity is left open.

References
  1. K. Mahesh Krishna, “C*-algebraic Schoenberg Conjecture”, arXiv:2206.06653 (2022).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

The general conjecture remains open, with only the two-factor case proved and an unverified submitted claim of a cubic matrix counterexample.

Krishna’s 2022 paper formulates the C∗C^*-algebraic extension of Schoenberg’s inequality and proves it for degree 22, leaving general degree open.

Known results

  • Degree 22 over any C∗C^*-algebra (Krishna, 2022).
  • Classical complex case, degree 33 (Schoenberg).
  • Classical complex case, degree 44 (Ivanov and Sharma, 1996).
  • Classical complex case, all degrees (Malamud and Pereira, 2003), by independent methods.

Community submission (unverified; October 28, 2026)

A submitted proof argues that one degree-33 matrix construction violates both adjoint inequalities, which would refute the C∗C^*-algebraic conjecture in general. This claim has not been independently verified.

Current status (as of October 2026): The degree-22 case is established; the general conjecture remains open, while a submitted degree-33 counterexample is unverified.

Sources

Solutions 1

One degree-three matrix construction refutes Krishna's C*-algebraic Schoenberg, de Bruin–Sharma and Kushel–Tyaglov conjectures. The ordered deletion derivative factors for every complex matrix argument, including noncommuting arguments. Both adjoint versions of each proposed inequality fail through exact negative quadratic forms. Lean proves the factorization and all six Hermitian failures.See full solutionHide full solution

One degree-three matrix construction refutes Krishna's C*-algebraic Schoenberg, de Bruin–Sharma and Kushel–Tyaglov conjectures. The ordered deletion derivative factors for every complex matrix argument, including noncommuting arguments. Both adjoint versions of each proposed inequality fail through exact negative quadratic forms. Lean proves the factorization and all six Hermitian failures. The common construction counts as one outcome; classical scalar results are unaffected.

AI-assisted preprint by Myeongjin Kang, with no affiliation. Internal AI review is not external journal peer review. The accompanying Lean certificate covers the precise scoped main statement; inspect the formal endpoint, assumptions and provenance in the supporting package. Prior-art investigations are documented bounded searches, not worldwide-priority certification. Original prose is offered under CC BY 4.0 and original code/Lean under MIT; third-party rights and existing notices are preserved. The public supporting ZIP contains original proof sources and verification evidence, with bibliographic links and hashes instead of redistributed third-party source manuscripts.

Recorded prior-art/source-access limits: Independent primary/citing/companion search found no prior refutation or subsuming negative theorem. Subscription indexes and systematic worldwide coverage unavailable. Parent addendum corrects ancillary review alternative-coefficient arithmetic, stale script docstring and an optional tautological loop; unchanged complete literal-source Lean and paper unaffected. No absolute priority guarantee.

Full paper: A cubic counterexample to three C*-algebraic polynomial inequalities.

Lean proof sources and pinned verification evidence: Zenodo supporting package. MathDB has not automatically verified the attached Lean certificate.