The bounded-exception conjecture for Markoff surface orbits

Let a,kZa,k\in\mathbb Z, and let

Ma,k:x2+y2+z2=axyz+k\mathcal M_{a,k}: x^2+y^2+z^2=axyz+k

be the Markoff surface over Z\mathbb Z, with GM\mathcal G_{\mathcal M} the group generated by the three involutions, double sign changes, and coordinate permutations. Bounded-exception conjecture. (a) There is a constant M1(a,k)M_1(a,k) such that for every prime pap\nmid a,

#Ma,k(Fp)#(largest GM-orbit in Ma,k(Fp))+M1(a,k).\#\mathcal M_{a,k}(\mathbb F_p)\leq \#\bigl(\text{largest $\mathcal G_{\mathcal M}$-orbit in $\mathcal M_{a,k}(\mathbb F_p)$}\bigr)+M_1(a,k).

(b) If #Ma,k(Z)=\#\mathcal M_{a,k}(\mathbb Z)=\infty, then there is a constant M2(a,k)M_2(a,k) such that for every prime pap\nmid a,

#Ma,k(Fp)#(Ma,k(Z)modp)+M2(a,k).\#\mathcal M_{a,k}(\mathbb F_p)\leq \#\bigl(\mathcal M_{a,k}(\mathbb Z)\bmod p\bigr)+M_2(a,k).

One may further ask whether M1(a,k)M_1(a,k) and M2(a,k)M_2(a,k) can be chosen independently of aa and kk. The source presents these assertions as conjectures motivated by finite orbits and lifting questions; no resolution is given.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Elena Fuchs, Matthew Litman, Joseph H. Silverman and Austin Tran, “Orbits on K3 Surfaces of Markoff Type”, arXiv:2201.12588 (2022).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.