Explicit parity-count generating function conjecture for generalized Fibonacci products
Fix and define as the generating function counting coefficients of that are congruent to modulo . Parity-count formula conjecture. For ,
This is presented as an empirically supported congruence analogue of an earlier denominator-shape conjecture; the source supplies no proof or resolution.
References
Primary source
Richard P. Stanley, “Theorems and Conjectures on Some Rational Generating Functions”, arXiv:2101.02131 (2021).
Progress summary
A reader-written complete proof has been posted, but it has not been independently verified, so the conjecture remains unresolved.
Richard P. Stanley’s 2021 paper conjectures that, for every , the parity-count generating function equals . The paper reports only scant evidence and supplies no proof.
Known results
- Stanley, 2021: rationality of the analogous is proved for ordinary Fibonacci products.
- For generalized Fibonacci products, rationality and the explicit parity formula remain stated as conjectures.
Posted attempt
A reader-written argument claims a complete proof for all : it uses canonical binary representatives, a finite-state parity count over , and derives the conjectured rational function. The attempt has not been independently verified.
Current status (as of August 2026): A complete proof has been posted but is unverified; the formula is not settled, and no verified proof, counterexample, or independent resolution is recorded.
Sources
Solutions 1
ProofThis solution needs a summarySee full solution
Fix , set , and let count the odd coefficients of
We prove
uniformly for every .
Read binary words from the lowest-index weight to the highest. The recurrence for the weights gives the weight-preserving rewrite
Every weight class therefore has a representative avoiding . By the free-monoid decomposition in Lemma 5.2, every nontrivial equal-weight pair generator has one row containing . Thus two avoiding representatives cannot differ, proving that each weight class has exactly one canonical representative.
Fix such a representative . The same free decomposition identifies all words of its weight with tilings of by singleton letters and blocks
where each star is an arbitrary binary letter. Consequently its coefficient is odd precisely when its number of these tilings is odd.
Over , let count completed tilings and count the stages of unfinished blocks. The initial vector is . Reading a zero or one gives
and a zero after consecutive ones is forbidden. A state accepts exactly when .
Encode the binary state vector by and retain the capped trailing-one count. All useful reachable states belong to the families
Here accept and do not. Direct substitution gives the complete transition graph
for every .
Write each state also for the generating function of its accepted continuations, and set , , . Summing the finite chains gives
These formal-power-series equations have a unique solution. With
direct substitution gives
The initial state is . Substituting proves the conjectured generating function for every .