Unit determinant conjecture for circulant matrices over finite chain rings
Let be a commutative finite chain ring (CFCR) of nilpotency index , and let be a positive integer. Let denote the ring of circulant matrices over , let be the group of units of , and let denote the determinant of . Unit determinant conjecture. Every unit of occurs as the determinant of a circulant matrix over :
Equivalently, for every unit . This extends the determinant-surjectivity result known under the restriction ; the source explains that surjectivity can fail for nonunits when this restriction is removed, but leaves the unit case open.
References
- Somphong Jitman, “Determinants of some Special Matrices over Commutative Finite Chain Rings”, arXiv:2007.14123 (2020).
Progress summary
A reader-supplied example claims the conjecture is false, but this counterexample has not been independently verified; the only published result covers the coprime case.
Jitman’s 2020 paper conjectures that every unit is the determinant of an circulant matrix over every commutative finite chain ring, without assuming .
Known results
- If , every element of , in particular every unit, occurs as a determinant (Jitman, 2020).
- Without this coprimality condition, surjectivity can fail for nonunits: is not the determinant of any matrix over (Jitman, 2020).
Posted attempt
A reader claims a counterexample with and : every determinant is in , so the unit is omitted. The calculation is not independently verified.
Current status (as of August 2026): The coprime case is proved, while the general unit conjecture has an unverified claimed counterexample and therefore remains mathematically unsettled.
Sources
Solutions 1
This solution needs a summarySee full solution
Take and . This is a commutative finite chain ring: its ideals are
its nilpotency index is , and its residue field is . Its units are and .
Every circulant matrix over has the form
Because has characteristic two,
Writing , with , gives
Consequently no circulant matrix has determinant , although . Hence
disproving the conjecture.