Hjorth–Kechris–Louveau strictness conjecture for Borel equivalence-relation hierarchies

For n3n\geq 3 and 0kn20\leq k\leq n-2, let n,k\cong^\ast_{n,k} be the equivalence relation whose invariants are pairs (A,R)(A,R) with AA a hereditarily countable set in Pn(N)\mathcal{P}^n(\mathbb{N}) and, for each aAa\in A, R(a,,)R(a,-,-) an injective map from AA into Pk(N)\mathcal{P}^k(\mathbb{N}). For a limit ordinal λ\lambda, define λ+1,β\cong^\ast_{\lambda+1,\beta} and λ+n,β\cong^\ast_{\lambda+n,\beta} analogously.

Hjorth–Kechris–Louveau strictness conjecture. The following Borel reducibilities are strict:

n,l<Bn,k\cong^\ast_{n,l}<_B\cong^\ast_{n,k}

for any n3n\geq 3 and l<kn2l<k\leq n-2;

λ+1,α<Bλ+1,β\cong^\ast_{\lambda+1,\alpha}<_B\cong^\ast_{\lambda+1,\beta}

for limit λ\lambda and α<β<λ\alpha<\beta<\lambda; and

λ+n,α<Bλ+n,β\cong^\ast_{\lambda+n,\alpha}<_B\cong^\ast_{\lambda+n,\beta}

for limit λ\lambda, n2n\geq 2, and α<βλ+n2\alpha<\beta\leq\lambda+n-2.

These conjectures concern whether the invariant hierarchies introduced by Hjorth, Kechris and Louveau collapse under Borel reducibility. The surrounding results establish maximality at several Borel complexity levels and stronger reducibility bounds for equivalence relations induced by abelian closed subgroups, but do not settle strictness.

Sources & referencesView supporting material

Primary source

Assaf Shani, “Borel reducibility and symmetric models”, arXiv:1810.06722 (2020).

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 0

No solutions have been posted yet.