Asymptotic size conjecture for the constructed system D
Let and let be the constructed maximal commutative algebraic system in . asymptotic-size conjecture. Is
Numerical checks through found ratios above and decreasing toward it. The conjecture asks whether the ratio converges to as tends to infinity.
References
- Victor A. Bovdi and Ho-Hon Leung, “Maximal commutative subalgebras of a Grassmann algebra”, arXiv:1803.03457 (2018).
Progress summary
A reader-submitted calculation claims the conjecture is true, but no independent verification has been found.
Bovdi and Leung posed the conjecture in 2018 for their maximal commutative algebraic system , asking whether its normalized size approaches . Their numerical tests supported this, but did not prove convergence.
Known results
- Bovdi and Leung (2018): is maximal and the computed ratios satisfy through .
- Bovdi and Leung (2018): and , with the observed sequence decreasing.
August 26, 2026 community submission
A submitted proof argues the exact identity
for , and concludes that the excess divided by tends to zero. If correct, this proves the conjecture; the argument is unverified and has no independent source.
Current status (as of August 2026): The original conjecture remains open in the published record; a community submission claims a complete proof, but that claim is unverified.
Sources
Solutions 1
This solution needs a summarySee full solution
Exact excess and the asymptotic size of
Statement
For , put
Section 4 of Bovdi and Leung's construction gives a maximal commutative algebraic system with
and no other layers. They conjecture that
We prove the stronger exact identity
In particular, the excess is positive for every , and its ratio to tends to zero. This proves the conjecture.
The odd upper tail
Let
Because is odd, complement symmetry gives
We also use the elementary alternating-tail identity
Here is even. Thus the difference between the even and odd terms in the upper half is
The odd terms in that upper half begin at , exactly the terms defining . Combining this observation with (3) gives
The exceptional layer
Write
The exceptional layer in (1) is
Since , Vandermonde's identity and give
Equations (5)--(7) therefore imply
The adjacent-binomial ratios are
Substitution into (8) yields
which is (2).
Taking the limit
The rational prefactor in (2) tends to , while the standard central-binomial estimate gives
Since , division of (2) by proves
This resolves the asymptotic-size conjecture.
Solved by the Principia Math harness. Check out our work at principia-math.com
Models used: GPT 5.6 Sol, Fable