← All problems

Grothendieck's homotopy hypothesis for infinity-groupoids

14 years old · traced to

Let Hot\mathsf{Hot} be the homotopy category of topological spaces, let CC be a coherator, and let Π∞‾\overline{\Pi_\infty} be the functor induced by the fundamental infinity-groupoid functor from topological spaces to Grothendieck infinity-groupoids of type CC, after localization at weak equivalences.

Grothendieck's conjecture. The functor Π∞‾\overline{\Pi_\infty} is an equivalence of categories.

This is Grothendieck's homotopy hypothesis, asserting that Grothendieck infinity-groupoids provide an algebraic model for homotopy types. The precise formulation depends on a coherator and the corresponding notion of weak equivalence; the source presents the assertion as a conjecture.

References
  1. Dimitri Ara, “On the homotopy theory of Grothendieck -groupoids”, arXiv:1206.2941 (2012).

Progress summary

Refreshed
Open

No independently verified resolution has been established; a community submission reports an unrefereed proof claim, while earlier work gives only partial and conditional results.

Grothendieck’s conjecture says that fundamental infinity-groupoids of type CC model all homotopy types, via an equivalence between spaces and localized Grothendieck infinity-groupoids. Ara’s formulation explicitly described the conjecture as unproved.

Known results

  • Ara, 2013: constructed Π∞\Pi_\infty, proved preservation of weak equivalences, and identified homotopy groups, but not the equivalence.
  • Henry, 2016: developed algebraic models and reduced the conjecture to an additional cylinder-coherator conjecture.
  • Ara–Métayer, 2019: established the homotopy hypothesis for Grothendieck 33-groupoids, conditional on the relevant semi-model structure.

Community submission (unverified), October 15, 2026

A submitted proof argues that an OpenAI preprint proves the full equivalence for every Grothendieck coherator in the Ara–Henry convention. The submission itself states that the preprint.

Current status (as of October 2026): The general conjecture remains open in the verified record; finite-dimensional and conditional results are known, while the submitted complete proof claim is unverified.

Sources

Solutions 2

Claimed by OpenAI. Claims the Grothendieck homotopy hypothesis for every Grothendieck coherator in the Ara–Henry convention and Henry's elementary-expansion pushout conjecture.See full solutionHide full solution

Scope relative to this problem: The claimed homotopy-category equivalence is for every Grothendieck coherator in the Ara-Henry infinity-groupoid convention and its stated weak equivalences, with the elementary-expansion pushout assertion. It does not claim Quillen equivalences for all weak (infinity,m)-categories at m>0 or every alternative coherator/model convention.

GitHub repository: https://github.com/openai/math

Manuscript: https://github.com/openai/math/blob/adc7f1241b42e322a6451854ab7e4b4c146bf78a/preprints/The-Grothendieck-homotopy-hypothesis-via-elementary-expansions-September-24-2026/paper.pdf

  • OpenAI-312-01-The-Grothendieck-homotopy-hypothesis-via-elementary-expansions.pdf504,898 bytesOpen
Lean category, not Solution: a complete Lean 4 proof of the conjecture as stated here (Ara's form): for every coherator, Π∞ sends weak homotopy equivalences to weak equivalences and induces Hot ≃ Ho(∞-Gpd_C). Repository cadamcat/homotopy-hypothesis-lean4, fixed version v1.0.0 (5481f84b), public 2026-10-15 03:58 UTC. Standard axioms only; fresh build, leanchecker and Comparator pass. The mathematics is OpenAI's claimed solution and Henry's framework; this post is the formalization.See full solutionHide full solution

Problem. Grothendieck's homotopy hypothesis for ∞-groupoids, in the form of D. Ara, On the homotopy theory of Grothendieck ∞-groupoids (arXiv:1206.2941), MathDB #323658.

Category. Lean. I, Yao Xu (@cadamcat), am the author of the formalization. I am not an author of the mathematical solution and claim only the Lean category.

Corresponding mathematical solution. OpenAI, The Grothendieck homotopy hypothesis via elementary expansions, OpenAI Math Release preprint dated September 24, 2026, at openai/math commit adc7f1241b42e322a6451854ab7e4b4c146bf78a (the solution already posted on this page). Its consequence of Cor. 4.2, the equivalence Hot ≃ Ho(∞-Gpd_C) induced by Π_∞, is the statement formalized. The formal proof follows S. Henry, Algebraic models of homotopy types and the homotopy hypothesis (arXiv:1609.04622), through cylinder categories and the comparison with spaces, with OpenAI's elementary expansion theorem as input. Both are unrefereed as far as I know.

Repository and version.

[
  {
    "repository": "https://github.com/cadamcat/homotopy-hypothesis-lean4",
    "branch": "main",
    "commit": "5481f84b13da0a14944ab7470441a7d4e53f3c55"
  }
]
  • 5481f84b13da0a14944ab7470441a7d4e53f3c55 is the annotated tag v1.0.0. The repository was published as that single commit.
  • Later commits on main change documentation only: aa41748cc39fe3b675935c13e0a30fb06bae5cbd adds the verification record docs/verification.md; later commits add a Chinese README and revise the README header and AUTHORS.md. No Lean file changed after v1.0.0.

Target theorem and statement.

def Statement : Prop :=
  ∀ (C : GlobularTheory.{u}) (hC : C.IsCoherator),
    Nonempty (TopRealization C) ∧
    ∀ R : TopRealization C,
      weakHomotopyEquivalences ≤
          (modelWeakEquivalences hC).inverseImage (fundamentalGroupoidFunctor R) ∧
        (fundamentalGroupoidFunctor R ⋙ (modelWeakEquivalences hC).Q).IsLocalization
          weakHomotopyEquivalences

Statement correspondence.

  • Coherators, ∞-groupoids of type C and their weak equivalences are copied verbatim from OpenAI's Comparator challenge GrothendieckElementaryExpansion.lean (namespace renamed, challenge theorem omitted). The definition matches Ara's coherators (admissible pairs, cellular tower, contractibility).
  • Π_∞. A TopRealization C is a functor C → Top sending the globes to the standard disks (Ara's hemisphere convention, up to isomorphism) and the globular-sum squares to pushouts; Π_R X is the model S ↦ Hom(R S, X). The statement asserts that a realization exists and quantifies over every realization.
  • Conclusion. Π_R sends weak homotopy equivalences (bijective on π₀ and on every πₙ at every base point) to weak equivalences, and Π_R followed by the localization is a localization of Top at the weak homotopy equivalences (Mathlib's Functor.IsLocalization): the induced functor Hot = Top[W⁻¹] → Ho(∞-Gpd_C), the page's Π_∞ with overline, is an equivalence of categories.
  • Universes. Any universe u; Statement.{0} is the set-level statement.
  • Not included: the existence of a coherator is not proved in Lean; the definition is OpenAI's own, and Ara's canonical coherator satisfies it mathematically.

Toolchain and dependencies. Lean leanprover/lean4:v4.34.1; Mathlib d13f23b723b8a846827a245b89c10fc7d3f11612, fixed in lake-manifest.json. OpenAI's Lean library on globular theories (Apache-2.0) is included unchanged under OAI/ and credited in THIRD_PARTY.md.

Reproduction.

git clone https://github.com/cadamcat/homotopy-hypothesis-lean4 && cd homotopy-hypothesis-lean4
git checkout 5481f84b13da0a14944ab7470441a7d4e53f3c55
lake exe cache get
./scripts/verify.sh

verify.sh builds the library and fails unless the main theorem's axioms are exactly the three below.

Axiom audit.

'HomotopyHypothesis.Blueprint.main' depends on axioms: [propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]

Verification of the fixed commit (fresh clone of v1.0.0; Lean 4.34.1):

  • clean build: exit 0, 9,645 jobs;
  • leanchecker --fresh HomotopyHypothesis.Blueprint.Main: exit 0;
  • Comparator ca04cfc7 with nanoda 3a240721, on Challenge.lean with the theorem as sorry and no definition holes: exit 0, accepted by nanoda and the Lean kernel;
  • controls: Comparator rejects a challenge with the universal quantifier over realizations replaced by an existential one ("Const does not match … HomotopyHypothesis.Statement"); nanoda rejects a sorry proof.

Original public date.

  • GitHub created_at: 2026-10-15T03:58:15Z; the activity feed records the creation of refs/heads/main at 5481f84b13da0a14944ab7470441a7d4e53f3c55 at 2026-10-15T03:58:24Z.
  • Software Heritage: save request 2558307, full visit at 2026-10-15T03:58:40Z, snapshot swh:1:snp:4478ccd81ef78e3883529c8b624aabd53e443760, containing main at that commit and tag v1.0.0.
  • Git commit and tag dates are author-set metadata.

Attribution. Mathematical solution: OpenAI (as posted on this page), following Henry's framework and Ara's formulation. Formalization: Yao Xu (AUTHORS.md). The Lean formalization was prepared by the author with AI assistance; all proofs are verified by the Lean 4 kernel.