← All problems

Zariski–Lipman conjecture

65 years old · traced to

Let kk be a field of characteristic zero and let RR be a finitely generated kk-algebra. For a commutative kk-algebra AA, write

Der⁡k(A)={ D∈End⁡k(A)  :  D(ab)=a D(b)+b D(a)  for all a,b∈A },\operatorname{Der}_{k}(A)=\{\, D\in\operatorname{End}_{k}(A) \;:\; D(ab)=a\,D(b)+b\,D(a)\ \text{ for all } a,b\in A \,\},

regarded as an AA-module via (aD)(b)=a D(b)(aD)(b)=a\,D(b).

Then for every prime ideal p⊂R\mathfrak p\subset R, if Der⁡k(Rp)\operatorname{Der}_{k}(R_{\mathfrak p}) is a free RpR_{\mathfrak p}-module, then the local ring RpR_{\mathfrak p} is regular.

Equivalently, in the localized form: for every prime p⊂R\mathfrak p\subset R,

Der⁡k(R)p free over Rp⟹Rp regular,\operatorname{Der}_{k}(R)_{\mathfrak p}\ \text{free over}\ R_{\mathfrak p}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad R_{\mathfrak p}\ \text{regular},

where Der⁡k(R)p\operatorname{Der}_{k}(R)_{\mathfrak p} denotes the localization at p\mathfrak p of the RR-module Der⁡k(R)\operatorname{Der}_{k}(R) (which is canonically isomorphic to Der⁡k(Rp)\operatorname{Der}_{k}(R_{\mathfrak p}), since Der⁡k(R)=Hom⁡R(ΩR/k,R)\operatorname{Der}_{k}(R)=\operatorname{Hom}_{R}(\Omega_{R/k},R) with ΩR/k\Omega_{R/k} a finitely presented RR-module).

Equivalent formulations
  1. In mathematics, the Nakai conjecture is an unproven characterization of smooth algebraic varieties, conjectured by Japanese mathematician Yoshikazu Nakai in 1961. It states that if V is a complex algebraic variety, such that its ring of differential operators is generated by the derivations it contains, then V is a smooth variety. The converse statement, that smooth algebraic varieties have rings of differential operators that are generated by their derivations, is a result of Alexander Grothendieck.

    source: Wikipedia

  2. Let kk be a field of characteristic zero, and let AA be the affine ring or the local analytic ring of a variety over kk. Zariski–Lipman conjecture. If

    Der1(A)Der^1(A)

    is AA-projective, then AA is regular. This conjecture is described in the source as a long-standing open problem in general cases, with recent progress cited there.

    source: Rui Li, Zida Xiao and Huaiqing Zuo, “The Nakai Conjecture for isolated hypersurface singularities of modality 2”, arXiv:2502.04672 (2025).

References
  1. J. Lipman, "Free derivation modules on algebraic varieties," American Journal of Mathematics 87 (1965), 874–88.
  2. Encyclopedia of Mathematics, Zariski–Lipman conjecture.

Source: Encyclopedia of Mathematics

Progress summary

Never refreshed

Nothing recorded yet. Refresh searches the literature and the public web for attempts on this problem, and writes the first summary here.

Solutions 1

Claimed by OpenAI. The manuscript claims a singular normal affine complex surface with free rank-two tangent sheaf, giving a characteristic-zero counterexample to Lipman-Zariski.See full solutionHide full solution